Source: Fox News
Introduction
A former attorney has been found guilty of attempted murder following a harrowing incident in which he attempted to shoot his ex-wife at point-blank range inside a Toledo restaurant. The chilling event, which was captured on surveillance video, unfolded while the victim was dining with her parents, turning a routine evening into a life-threatening ordeal.
Matthew Exton, 43, faced a jury trial for his actions on April 11, 2025, when he targeted his ex-wife, Kada Malone. The conviction, handed down on September 4, marks a significant legal conclusion to a case defined by premeditated violence and a startling display of courtroom volatility.
What Happened
The incident began at the Sabira restaurant, where Malone was seated with her parents, Jeannie and Charles Malone. Exton, who had been consuming alcohol at the nearby Souk establishment earlier that day, entered Sabira and approached the family’s table. He proceeded to order a drink for the group, spat in their direction, and briefly exited the premises.
Security footage reveals that Exton returned shortly thereafter armed with a handgun. He moved directly toward his ex-wife, pressing the weapon against her head at point-blank range. As Malone raised her hands in a desperate attempt to protect her face, Exton pulled the trigger. The firearm failed to discharge, a malfunction investigators later attributed to the safety mechanism remaining engaged.
Before Exton could attempt a second shot, a restaurant employee intervened by tackling him from behind. Law enforcement officials later confirmed that the firearm was loaded, with a round chambered and seven additional bullets contained within the magazine.
Background
Exton, a former lawyer and local prosecutor, had reportedly engaged in a pattern of threatening behavior leading up to the attack. During the trial, prosecutors highlighted a voicemail left for Malone that quoted lyrics from the Johnny Cash song "God's Gonna Cut You Down." The prosecution argued that this communication served as a clear indicator of Exton’s hostile state of mind and intent.
The trial was marked by intense courtroom behavior. During closing arguments, Exton experienced a disruptive outburst, leading to his removal from the courtroom by bailiffs. Reports indicate that he shouted the lyrics to the same song he had referenced in his prior threatening voicemail and directed a gun-like finger gesture toward assistant prosecutor Rose Mock.
Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| April 11, 2025 | Attempted shooting at Sabira restaurant in Toledo. |
| September 4, 2026 | Jury reaches a guilty verdict for attempted murder and felonious assault. |
| September 21, 2026 | Scheduled date for formal sentencing. |
Key Details
| Category | Details |
|---|---|
| Defendant | Matthew Exton (43) |
| Victims | Kada Malone, Jeannie Malone, Charles Malone |
| Charges | Attempted murder, two counts of felonious assault, two firearm specifications |
| Weapon Status | Loaded with one in the chamber, seven in the magazine; safety was on |
Impact
Lucas County Prosecuting Attorney Julia R. Bates issued a formal statement following the verdict, emphasizing the gravity of the defendant's actions. She described the incident not as a spontaneous act, but as a calculated attempt to carry out a public execution. Bates extended her gratitude to the restaurant staff and patrons who intervened, labeling them as heroes for their bravery in preventing a potential tragedy.
The court took measures to ensure the integrity of the trial, with the judge explicitly instructing the jury to disregard Exton’s disruptive outbursts. The legal proceedings underscored the broader implications of domestic violence and the severe risks posed when threats escalate into targeted public attacks.
What Happens Next
Following the jury's guilty verdict on the charges of attempted murder and two counts of felonious assault, the case moves toward its final phase. Exton remains in custody following his removal from the courtroom during the closing arguments. The court has scheduled the formal sentencing for September 21, 2026, at which time the judge will determine the punishment for the convicted former attorney.
